If the Employer fails to prove the initial formulated charge(s) against the employee, can the employee be found guilty and dismissed on a competent charge against them?
The Labour Court in Avril Elizabeth Home for the Mentally Handicapped v. Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others (2006) 27 IL 1644 (LC) determined that the LRA contemplates an informal, quick disciplinary process that calls for, in essence, nothing more than a conversation and an opportunity for reflection before a decision is made to dismiss … If the Employer fails to prove the initial formulated charge(s) against the employee, can the employee be found guilty and dismissed on a competent charge against them?